Definitions
Please refer to the University’s Intellectual Property - Governing Policy and Glossary of Terms for policies and procedures for terms and definitions used in these procedures. These are critical to its interpretation and effectiveness.
1. Purpose of procedures
This document sets out the University’s procedures in relation to the commercialisation of intellectual property, other than the University teaching materials and from intellectual property not derived from research. It provides guidance to staff, students and invited scholars about the framework at the University for dealing with the commercialisation of intellectual property.
These procedures complement the University’s Intellectual Property - Governing Policy and are compliant with the University’s obligations under the National Principles of Intellectual Property Management for Publicly Funded Research.
2. What is commercialisation?
One of the primary functions of the University, as demonstrated by the University’s learning and teaching activities, is that of community service. That function is also demonstrated by the University’s objective in leveraging its research and scholarly endeavours to enable productive partnerships including the translation of research benefits for the benefit of the wider community.
The commercialisation of intellectual property is the process by which the outcomes of research at the University reach the community, for social, public good or monetary gain. Commercialisation is a complex and often lengthy process and requires commitment and diligence. There are a variety of pathways to commercialisation and numerous steps are involved in the process.
3. Why commercialise? – community benefit
Community benefit is often achieved by putting the University’s research outcomes, the results of staff and students and or invited scholars innovation and inventiveness, into the public domain to achieve measurable impact. This is done via a number of mechanisms such as publication, policy change, knowledge transfer and industry adoption. As a result of this, the community is informed about, and is able to benefit from, the University’s research outcomes.
In terms of industry adoption, this occurs when the innovation and inventiveness of staff and students and invited scholars is disseminated into an industry or sector, and that industry or sector then adopts the new knowledge created.
However, for some research, commercialisation may not occur unless there is investment in the technology, to take technology into a market ready state. That investment is usually undertaken by an industry partner who is a collaborator, or an investor into a start-up company, or a licensee. For other disciplines of research, commercialisation may not occur unless the University partners with a commercial partner with the skills and resources to successfully commercialise.
Where community benefit can only be achieved by forming an alliance with an industry partner or investor, and that alliance does not occur, the results may be less than optimal. The technology may never reach a market ready state, or those skills and resources may not be accessed, and the community as a result may never benefit from the University’s research outcomes in this particular area.
To achieve the community objective that the outcomes of the University’s research be beneficial to the community, the University will facilitate and promote commercialisation of intellectual property, including by forming alliances with industry partners and investors.
Some examples of alliances with industry partners are:
(a) granting a licence of Intellectual Property to a commercial partner to exploit intellectual property
(b) entering into contract research agreements to undertake research at commercial rates
(c) spinning out a start-up company into which intellectual property is licensed or assigned, and into which a venture capitalist or other investor makes an investment to fund research and development
(d) spinning out a company that becomes operational and trades, and pursues a business opportunity
(e) assigning Intellectual Property to a commercial partner.
4. Why commercialise? – increasing the University’s resources
The process of commercialisation may therefore necessarily result in the University having relationships with industry partners. Often, these will be research relationships, where an industry partner will financially support research at the University.
If commercialisation is successful other financial returns may flow to the University including royalties or the benefits of a shareholding in a spin out company which will increase the sources of revenue for the University. This additional revenue may facilitate further research activity.
5. Why commercialise? – rewarding innovation and inventiveness
Additionally, the University wants to personally reward staff and students whose inventiveness and innovation has resulted in successful commercialisation.
The Intellectual Property - Governing Policy sets out the framework for the distribution of commercialisation revenues to staff, students and invited scholars whose inventiveness and innovation has resulted in successful commercialisation.
6. Won't Commercialisation impede publication?
The University acknowledges the interests of Staff, Students and Invited Scholars in publishing their research and seeks to facilitate the publication of that research, whilst respecting the rights of parties with whom the University has contractual obligations. In addition, the University seeks to foster the translation of research for broad community benefit, a process that may be facilitated through the protection of the University intellectual property.
The University acknowledges that best practice outcomes in commercialisation may be achieved if the University is consulted prior to disclosure of the University’s intellectual property having commercial potential.
Staff, students and invited scholars must not disclose the University’s intellectual property having commercial potential to third parties (including editors of publications and journals) unless they have advised the Office of Research in writing with reasonable notice to enable assessment.
7. Role of Creators in Managing and Commercialising Intellectual Property
7.1 Who is a Creator
The Intellectual Property - Governing Policy provides the definition of a ‘Creator’ for the purposes of these procedures.
7.2 The Role of Creator
Creators of intellectual property have a critical role to play in assisting in the management and commercialisation of intellectual property.
The University relies on its staff, students and invited scholars to play an active and dedicated part in the management and commercialisation of intellectual property, without which the University cannot achieve the community benefit objectives for which it strives.
7.3 Expectations upon Creators
The University recognises that much of the University's research output will realise its community benefit role via publications that may not have commercialisation potential. However significant research output may also have commercial value. To maximise the commercialisation outcomes of this research for researchers, the University and the community, decisions should be made to protect and commercialise these outputs.
The University’s expectation is that creators of the University’s intellectual property will help the University achieve the optimal community benefit able to be achieved for the intellectual property developed at the University to be meaningful and beneficial. The Office of Research will undertake education and training for staff, students and invited scholars to support them in realising these expectations.
The University’s expectation is that creators of the University’s intellectual property will:
(a) identify intellectual property that may have commercialisation prospects
(b) disclose that identified intellectual property via forms available on the UniSC website
(c) confer with the University on the timing of publications to ensure that publication and intellectual property protection may be achieved without either hindering the other
(d) assist the University in the assessment, management, protection, and commercialisation of intellectual property
(e) assist the University in inventorship, authorship and contributor determinations
(f) ensure that the University is engaged in any process of application for patents
(g) ensure that the University is involved in the engagement of any patent attorneys
(h) work with patent attorneys engaged by the University, including preparing parts or drafts of patent specifications
(i) assist the University in preparing other documents that will assist in the protection and commercialisation of intellectual property including technical descriptions and evaluations, and market descriptions and evaluations
(j) sign documents required in the patent application process within an agreed timeframe
(k) answer questions and provide information requested by the University within an agreed timeframe
(l) promptly notify the University when approached by a possible commercial partner
(m) assist the University in its negotiations with commercial partners
(n) include the University in any commercial discussions relating to intellectual property
(o) ensure that the University is consulted about, and agrees to, the signing of any contracts or commitments binding upon the University and
(p) seek the University approval for any media statements regarding Intellectual Property with commercial potential.
Similarly, the University’s expectation is that the Office of Research will use its best endeavours to respond within a timely and commercial timeframe.
8. Identification and Disclosure of Intellectual Property
8.1 Identification of Intellectual Property
The University relies on staff, students and invited scholars in consultation to identify commercialisable intellectual property. staff, students and invited scholars need to be alert to identifying commercialisable intellectual property, as often, commercialisable intellectual property is created, but not recognised as intellectual property, or not recognised as commercialisable.
This represents a loss of opportunity:
(a) to the University in terms of its reputation and in the achievement of its community obligations
(b) to the staff, students and invited scholars that created that intellectual property, who by reason of the lost opportunity do not receive commercialisation revenue benefits as well as scholarly recognition
(c) to the school in which the staff or students created that intellectual property, which by reason of the lost opportunity does not receive commercialisation revenue that may have been available to fund further research by those staff, students and invited scholars.
The University relies upon staff, students and invited scholars, working with the Office of Research, to identify commercialisable intellectual property, as the University has no other means of ascertaining what intellectual property has been developed at the University. The Office of Research will make its best endeavours to assist in this process.
A complete disclosure of commercialisable intellectual property to the Office of Research must be promptly made by staff, students and invited scholars.
8.2 Manner of making an Intellectual Property disclosure
Creators disclose intellectual property by completing a creator disclosure form which is available on the University’s website.
The website also contains guidelines for the completion of the creator disclosure form.
9. Assessment of Intellectual Property derived from Research
9.1 Initial assessment
The Office of Research will make an initial assessment of the intellectual property disclosed in a creator Disclosure Form.
That assessment will be made with the assistance of the creators.
The assessment will include such matters as:
(a) the Commercialisation prospects of the Intellectual Property
(b) the appropriateness of seeking the protection of the intellectual property, for example, by filing a patent application
(c) whether it would be prudent to undertake further work or research on the intellectual property to bring it to a more commercialisable state
(d) sources of research monies for further research
(e) commercialisation strategies
(f) potential industry partners.
This list is by no means intended to be exhaustive.
The Office of Research will make its best endeavours to undertake this assessment within an appropriate commercial timeframe, and will inform the creators of any time constraints that may impact upon this process.
The Office of Research’s assessment will encompass all relevant factors to thoroughly assess the intellectual property and the commercialisation opportunity.
9.2 Continuous assessment
The Office of Research will make continuous assessments of intellectual property.
Intellectual property and the landscape in which it is commercialised is dynamic. As a result, different commercialisation strategies may be employed as further research is undertaken.
Initial assessments are therefore subject to continuous review, and further assessment of the commercialisation opportunity, to maximise the opportunity for the University.
10. Protection of Intellectual Property
There are many different ways to obtain protection for intellectual property. The Office of Research, in making these assessments, may seek advice of patent attorneys, creators and other experts as appropriate in order to determine the best approach for each individual case.
10.1 Patenting
The Office of Research will be responsible for assessing:
(a) whether to apply for a patent
(b) the timing of a patent application
(c) the scope of protection to be sought
(d) whether to proceed from a provisional application to a patent cooperation treaty application
(e) whether to proceed to national filings of a patent application.
The Office of Research will implement those decisions and manage the prosecution of patents.
10.2 Other forms of protection
Office of Research will also be responsible for making similar assessments in relation to other forms of intellectual property.
Office of Research will also implement those decisions and manage the prosecution of those applications.
10.3 Publications and seeking Intellectual Property protection
The transfer of knowledge and technology through publication and commercialisation has always been, and remains, an important function of the University, and as such, the University encourages staff, students and invited scholars to publish their research findings in academic and scholarly journals, and recognises the importance of both in terms of career progression.
At the same time, commercialisable intellectual property may sometimes need to be maintained in confidence, so as not to affect adversely its commercialisation prospects.
But the objective to commercialise intellectual property is not to operate to the exclusion of the objective to publish. The two objectives are not mutually exclusive, but should be complementary, each supporting the other. Indeed, publication is a valuable commercialisation tool, demonstrating that publication and commercialisation, far from being mutually exclusive, should be complementary, each supporting the other.
Intellectual Property that is disclosed to the Office of Research, can and should be the subject of publications.
The Office of Research will work with contributors to maximise:
(a) The opportunities for the publication of commercialisable intellectual property
(b) The commercial opportunities of commercialisable intellectual property.
In practice, this will mean that the Office of Research and creators will work together to formulate timetables that:
(c) Do not unnecessarily hinder publications
(d) Do not put the protection and commercialisation of intellectual property at risk.
This will preserve the achievement of both objectives in a cooperative fashion, without the achievement of either objective hindering the other.
11. Distribution of Net Commercialisation Revenue
The University will distribute net commercialisation revenue it receives from the commercialisation of the University’s intellectual property in accordance with the Intellectual Property: Commercialisation Revenue - Procedures and associated guidelines.
END